Rhett Butler’s People by Donald McCaig

Rhett Butler’s People
Donald McCaig

3 book marks

Great characters live on long after the final pages of our favorite books, subject to our wild imaginations.  In the final pages of Margaret Mitchell’s Gone With the Wind, our minds are already working on what could happen next when Scarlett vows, “I’ll think of some way to get him back.  After all…tomorrow is another day.”

For decades, we wondered if Rhett and Scarlett would get back together.  To answer our curiosity, Alexandra Ripley wrote Scarlett in 1992.  Then Donald McCaig wrote Rhett Butler’s People in 2007 and Ruth’s Journey in 2014.

Gone With the Wind has inspired other books as well, including The Wind Is Never Gone:  Sequels, Parodies and Rewritings of Gone With the Wind by M. Carmen Gómez-Galisteo; Scarlett’s Women:  Gone With the Wind and Its Female Fans by Helen Taylor; Frankly, My Dear:  “Gone With the Wind Revisited” by Molly Haskell; and the parody by Alice Randall, The Wind Done Gone.

Rhett Butler’s People is a saga of the Butler family in Charleston, South Carolina before, during and after the Civil War, and is a companion piece to GWTW.  It begins with a fateful duel of honor and jumps back to Rhett’s boyhood days on the family’s rice plantation.  It’s no surprise that Rhett is a rebel and McCaig takes the reader through Rhett’s many clashes with his controlling father, Langston Butler.  The back story ties into what the reader already knows about Rhett from GWTW and the author fills in the plot with new characters to interact with some of GWTW’s main characters, including Melanie Hamilton, Ashley Wilkes and Belle Watling.  Some new characters are Rhett’s little sister, Rosemary, school companions Andrew Ravanel and Edgar Puryear and Belle Watling’s bastard son, Tazewell.

Although Rhett and Scarlett meet under the same circumstances at Twelve Oaks, McCaig tells the story from the Butler angle and follows Rhett through his blockade running days during the war and as he meets up with Scarlett in Atlanta.  McCaig, who also wrote Canaan and Jacob’s Ladder, is a Civil War expert and, in his story, he describes the major conflicts between the north and south, slavery and the war’s impact on the southern way of life.

While no story can compare to a classic like Gone With the Wind, McCaig fills in a lot of nice details about the Butler family.  The story is at its strongest between McCaig’s original characters and the complicated dynamic within the Watling family, and less so, however, when he retells scenes from GWTW.  It’s always risky to pick up characters from another book and the author’s portrayals of Melanie and Belle, in particular, will seem a little off to GWTW fans.  In addition, Rhett’s character seems too soft and too understanding to be the swaggering, dangerous and irresistible Rhett we swoon over in GWTW.

Rhett Butler’s People is a well-told story, however, with lots of interesting side characters and plots, painting a vivid picture of the south during the war.  In addition, readers are rewarded with a wild and satisfying finish.  A fun read inspired by a great classic!

If you love historical fiction about the Civil War, check out my review of Gone With the Wind by Margaret Mitchell.

Thanks for visiting – come back soon!


14 thoughts on “Rhett Butler’s People by Donald McCaig

  1. I’m impressed when writers are inspired by a film / book and come up with an original story of their own, often filling in on back story etc. To take on GWTW is a courageous move and this sounds intriguing and well done…I might well take a look. Great review and interesting with all the information around other GWTW books – I had no idea they were out there!

  2. Hi Barb: for some reason although I am following you, I am not getting your blogs. Not sure what is happening. A bunch of my usual follows have dropped. Will try hitting the follow button again – if nothing works will give myself a reminder to stop by! Thanks for the tweet!

    1. Hi Ann! I know, I didn’t either but my work friend and I got on the topic of GWTW and she let me borrow this one. I think she has Ruth’s Story too, but I may take a break before I read another. It’s good as a stand alone book, but it’s hard to compare to GWTW. Thanks for reading and commenting!

  3. Omg. Must. Read. This. Book!!!!! I was just bemoaning not having a book to read me came across your review. Gonna go look for it on my kindle now! Thanks. GWTW is one of my all time faves. Xo!

      1. I read the reviews after I finished. I thought it was entertaining and fun to read. I had some issues with Melanie and Belle and I thought Rhett was a little too nice. It’s definitely not GWTW, but it’s much better than Scarlett. I guess I’d say read it with an open mind and know that there will never be another GWTW!

Tell me what you're thinking!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s