The Swans of Fifth Avenue by Melanie Benjamin

The Swans of Fifth Avenue
Melanie Benjamin


Someone should have warned the elegant and famously wealthy socialites of New York not to reveal their deepest secrets to the famous author and scandal-loving gossiper, Truman Capote! Years earlier, Capote had been welcomed into their fold and became their treasured confidante. The result was a story that shook high society and ended close friendships. “La Côte Basque 1965” was published in 1975 by Esquire magazine as a preview chapter of Answered Prayers, Capote’s last and unfinished novel. Capote had been gathering material for years about this social set and in it, he held nothing back.

Truman Capote/Image: Wikipedia

The Swans of Fifth Avenue is the fictionalized account of Capote’s friendship with six women, Babe Paley, Slim Keith, Pamela Harriman, Marella Agnelli, Gloria Guinness and CZ Guest. Capote arrived on the New York social scene in the fifties and became fast friends with these ladies, especially Babe Paley, who was married to CBS founder, Bill Paley. High society did not know what to think of Capote’s unusual and flamboyant style, but they took to him because he was so much fun. And the husbands didn’t mind because his homosexuality made him a safe companion. But, although Capote was often the life of the party, he was also a well-respected author of short fiction and several novels, including Breakfast at Tiffany’s. His masterpiece, In Cold Blood, was still to come.

The women were known as Capote’s swans, and spent their days shopping, having luncheons, attending galas and retreating to vacation homes. Wherever they went, they were impeccably dressed and ready to be photographed at any angle. Many of the swans, especially Babe, considered it their jobs to look perfect. It was serious business being a trophy wife: the women had no earning power other than being bred to marry a rich husband.

Babe Paley/Image: Wikipedia

In particular, Benjamin portrays Babe as a lonely and insecure woman, whose husband, a notorious womanizer, valued her beauty, but only as a means to elevate his status. Separate bedrooms underscored their lack of intimacy and, desperate for his affection, Babe was intent on being perfect and creating the perfect home. She left no detail to chance, anticipating her husband’s every need, even when he hardly noticed. For Babe, Truman came at the right time, filling a painful void.

The Swans of Fifth Avenue is a highly entertaining account of a period of time in New York that hit its peak just as Capote did. And as Capote began his slide into alcohol and drug abuse, the swans became matrons and had to move aside for a new generation. Benjamin feeds the reader’s need to admire the fashion and lifestyles of the super wealthy, while also showing its emptiness and sadness. Marriage is never till death do us part, and while Babe stays married to Bill, the other swans have affairs, marry, and divorce several times over.

Of course, the swans spent money like no one else and so the question is: how much can the average reader feel sorry for them? They certainly enjoyed the power and attention that their status gave them and the many pictures from the society pages suggest they knew exactly what they were doing, even Babe.

In addition, Benjamin presents a fascinating portrait of Truman Capote and his distinct sides, as both pet and confidante as well as a serious writer. I highly recommend The Swans of Fifth Avenue to readers who enjoy character studies and stories about the New York upper class.

Thanks for visiting – come back soon!

14 thoughts on “The Swans of Fifth Avenue by Melanie Benjamin

    1. Totally enjoyed it – very entertaining, but definitely not cheesy, plus she seems to be very accurate with the facts and the fiction part seems realistic. Thanks for reading and commenting, Jill!

  1. Barbara, a terrific review and as I have read some of Capote’s work and been intrigued by his books, this is one I’d love to read. Going on my list! Thank you for sharing …

  2. Ah, sounds terrific! I’d seen the cover before, but hadn’t looked into it enough to know that it was about Truman Capote and his social circle. It does sound like a great read!

    1. I’ve had the book for a couple years, but just got around to reading it. So glad I did. Melanie Benjamin is a very good writer. Thanks for stopping by, Lisa!

  3. Irresistible! What’s more fun than being a fly on the wall of the super-wealthy, gasping at the glamour while being reassured that these women led empty lives? Going on my list 😉

    1. Hi Jan – Yes I agree. I really enjoyed this book. I also read The Paris Wife by Benjamin which is about Ernest Hemingway. She’s a very good writer! Thanks for stopping by!

  4. So at first I thought this was non-fiction, but it’s actually Historical Fiction? I was thinking to myself that this sounded interesting and I don’t usually like non-fiction, so it definitely sounds more up my alley if it’s fiction. Great review!

    1. Oh wow I realize now how much my review it sounds like it’s nonfiction – but it’s definitely fictionalized. It’s seems so close to the real events but the dialogue is all fiction. Thanks for reading and commenting, Stephanie!

  5. Sounds fascinating, and what a fantastic review! I think it’s a misconception that just because people have a lot of money we shouldn’t feel sorry for them for having sad, empty lives and marriages. True, at least they’re not starving and they’re living in luxury, but there are poor people who are happy and rich people who are miserable – the money is immaterial at times.

Comments are closed.