Book Review: Near Prospect Park by Lawrence H. Levy

Near Prospect Park
Lawrence H. Levy

In Near Prospect Park, Brooklyn detective Mary Handley takes on New York’s upper crust as she works with Lillian Russell, Diamond Jim Brady and Teddy Roosevelt to solve her husband’s murder.

It’s 1895 and Mary is happily married to Harper Lloyd, an investigative journalist. Despite also caring for their baby daughter, Mary still has her feet in detective work. For Mary is a modern woman, unwilling to sacrifice her ambition and independence to society’s (and her opinionated mother’s) expectations.

William S. Gilbert (of the comic opera team Gilbert and Sullivan) has hired Mary to help him retrieve a ransomed manuscript and, with four thousand in cash, Mary agrees to make the exchange with the thief in Prospect Park. But the meeting goes wrong and in the shocking aftermath, Mary discovers that Harper has been murdered. Fueled on grief and rage, Mary sets out to find his killer.

Mary first turns to her contacts in the Gilbert case, who include actress Lillian Russell and railroad supplies magnate Diamond Jim Brady. Through them, she soon becomes acquainted with blue blood bad boys Stanford White and James Breese. White, a famous architect and photographer and financier Breese have been linked to a raucous party in which fifteen-year-old Susie Johnson was hired to jump out of a pie. Johnson’s claims of rape were largely quashed by the powerful elite. But Mary has not forgotten the scandal of the Pie Girl Dinner and, despite investigating Harper’s murder, she knows she must also get to the bottom of this atrocious behavior. Teddy Roosevelt, president of the New York police commissioners and a strong supporter of women’s rights, also has Mary’s back.

Mary is a risk-taker, but a confident one, for she is a master in jujitsu and she has flattened many foes with her quick moves. She will need these skills as she digs deeper into the case.

I enjoyed this fast-moving and entertaining historical mystery. As in his earlier books, the author includes many historical figures and brings their personalities to life. New York in the 1890s was a rough place, especially for women. The Pie Girl Dinner, an actual event, is just one example of how crimes against women are nothing new.

As in the earlier Mary Handley Mysteries, Near Prospect Park is an enjoyable mystery that incorporates humor into serious themes. Mary’s character is strong, yet vulnerable, making her relatable, even in modern times. I’m looking forward to more Mary Handley adventures!

Want more? Check out these other Mary Handley Mysteries.

Second Street Station (Book 1)
Brooklyn on Fire (Book 2)
Last Stop in Brooklyn (Book 3)

Author Interview – Lawrence H. Levy

Thanks for visiting – come back soon!

29 thoughts on “Book Review: Near Prospect Park by Lawrence H. Levy

  1. The title and setting reminded me immediately of Pulitzer Prize winning Age of Innocence, by Edith Wharton, who drew upon her insider’s knowledge of the upper class New York “aristocracy.”

    Thanks, Barbara, for sifting through so many books and introducing me to this title.

    1. Hi Marian – ah yes I read The Age of Innocence and enjoy reading about the NY upper class. I also liked The Swans of Fifth Avenue which is about Truman Capote and his friendships with the upper crust “Swans.” A different era but equally interesting. Thanks for the visit 🙂

    1. Hi Robbie – yes and it cand be read as a standalone – there are a few minor references to the earlier books, but nothing that would take away from the story. Thanks for the visit!

    1. Hi Books and Bakes – I think it’s an interesting time period to write about and I haven’t read many books set during this time. Thanks for reading and commenting. Hope you’re reading something good, planning a fun outing or baking something yummy right now!

      1. Trying not to melt really! It’s very warm here. I’m off to research some books from that time period/set in that time period. Thanks so much Book Club Mom. Fabulous post as ever. X

      2. Well the sun finally came out – 2 weeks ago we got 8 inches of rain in a span of about 4 hours – it was terrible! Tons of trees came down and we lost power for 24 hours. We were lucky because some people had no power for a week. I can’t tell you how nice it was to get all the comforts back 🙂

    1. Hi Stephanie – well we all have genres we prefer – I like historical fiction a lot, but in proportion with other types of books. I wouldn’t want to read just one genre. Thanks for the visit!

    1. Hi TanGental – thank you for the compliment. I also like visiting other blogs with reviews from genres I don’t always read. It’s good to know what’s out there, I think. Thanks for your support 🙂

Tell me what you're thinking!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s