Book Review: Razorblade Tears by S.A. Cosby

Razorblade Tears
S.A. Cosby

Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

I know to be wary about books that get a lot of hype, but I fell for it this time. When I saw the critical acclaim from The New York Times, NPR, The Washington Post and many others, naming Razorblade Tears one of the best books of 2021, I wanted to read it.

In the beginning, I thought I was part of that cheering crowd, but I soon changed my mind. Here’s the premise of the book:

Ike Randolph and Buddy Lee Jenkins are two ex-cons whose gay sons, Isiah and Derek (married to each other) were gunned down outside a wine shop in Richmond, Virginia. When Buddy Lee suggests they combine forces to avenge their sons’ deaths, Ike agrees.

Ike, a successful Black business owner, has kept a clean record in the fifteen years he’s been out of prison for manslaughter. And he’s kept his violent temper at bay. He needs to, especially now that he and his wife have custody of three-year-old, Arianna, Isiah and Derek’s daughter. Buddy Lee, who is white, is a career con man and an alcoholic, living in a dilapidated trailer. On top of their grief, they have many regrets about shunning their sons for their homosexuality. Now they have a chance to make things a little better.

They soon learn that Ike’s son, Isiah, a journalist, was about to expose a scandalous relationship between a woman named Tangerine and an unnamed powerful man she’d met. On the other side, this powerful person has hired a hit man and his violent gang to find Tangerine and kill her before the story gets out.

Over a period of several days, Ike and Buddy Lee chase the killers and the killers chase them. And there are many violent casualties along the way, described in graphic detail. Between the violence, they move towards friendship as they joke around and share their struggles about accepting their sons. Ike also sets Buddy Lee straight on a number of racial assumptions. I thought these were good ways to bring out the subtleties of racism, one of the better parts of the book.

I was interested in the premise, but honestly, the rest of the book just isn’t that good, with all kinds of weird metaphors and choppy sentences. Razorblade Tears is described as noir fiction, and as a reader you have to accept the violence as part of the genre, but I found the characters to be stereotypical and the fight scenes hard to follow. In addition, to say you must suspend all disbelief is a huge understatement.

In the end, I felt manipulated by the hype and in the heavy-handed message about race, gender, sexuality, and a host of other social issues. I felt this could have been a much better book if the author had focused more on the characters and had chosen one or two issues.

Other WordPress bloggers have written mixed reviews. You can check them out here.

Books with Chai
The Lesser Joke
The BiblioSanctum

Thanks for visiting – come back soon!

25 thoughts on “Book Review: Razorblade Tears by S.A. Cosby

  1. This would not be my cup of tea either. I usually wait until someone who has similar tastes as mine in reading to recommend a book. Often movies and books that are very popular with the general public aren’t ones I enjoy.

    1. I think we’re the same, Darlene. But sometimes I wait a long time to read a book that had a lot of hype and discover how great it was. Usually it’s the other way around though. Thanks for reading and commenting.

  2. Thanks for the honest review, Barb. I made it a point to read several books that were on the bestseller list in newspapers this year and overall was disappointed. I have no idea WHO made them bestsellers. Lots of hype for not much. I prefer to rely on my blogging buddies.

    1. We just had a discussion at dinner tonight on the same subject. Honestly, I’m going to do what you’re doing and rely on my blogging friends. Thanks for the visit, Noelle!

  3. I’m glad to read your review and temper my expectations! I’ve seen some stellar reviews, but it’s really good to see another viewpoint. I don’t always tolerate violence in my fiction choices — I’ll approach with caution. Great review!

  4. Good to see such a thoughtful review — not easy to do when you haven’t really enjoyed the book. I haven’t seen the hype for this one yet myself, so I’ll do a wait-and-see 🙂

    1. Hi Jan, thanks for stopping by. I don’t like leaving negative reviews, but this book really bothered me. It made me mad that it was so highly recommended!

Comments are closed.