Book Review: Five Total Strangers by Natalie D. Richards

Five Total Strangers
Natalie D. Richards

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

This Young Adult thriller is just as good or better than many of the adult thrillers I’ve recently read! Five Total Strangers is about Mira Hayes, a high school art student traveling home for Christmas from San Diego to Pittsburgh. When a snowstorm strands her in Newark, she accepts a ride from Harper Chung, her seatmate on the flight. Harper, a college student at Pomona, has rented an SUV and offered rides to three others: Brecken, an intense pre-med student from UC Berkeley, Josh, a tall blond with sleepy eyes and a knee brace and Kayla, a willowy girl who sleeps a lot. At first, Mira thinks the others all know each other, but she soon discovers that they are all strangers, with an emphasis on strange.

But Mira doesn’t care as long as she gets home for Christmas. It’s just Mira and her mom this year and it’s also the anniversary of her aunt’s death, her mother’s twin. Plus she’s just discovered that her mom and stepfather have split. After a year of helping her mom through a devastating loss, Mira has become her mother’s emotional caretaker and getting home is a must.

Treacherous driving conditions become the first layer of suspense. Then, one by one, the strangers’ belongings, important ones, go missing. Someone is lying and Mira doesn’t know whom to trust. Things get weirder when they stop along the way and outsiders become involved. As tension builds, Mira asks herself, “What if one of us isn’t in this car to get home at all? What if one of us got in this car for all the wrong reasons?”

I don’t want to give anything away, so I’ll stop with the plot development! I thought this was an excellent story and that the characters were realistic teens and early twenty-somethings. Like Mira, readers won’t be sure who’s trustworthy and who’s evil because they all have secrets (even Mira, who hasn’t told them she’s only in high school). Harper keeps looking at her phone in horror. Brecken smiles like a wolf. Josh doesn’t want help or attention and Kayla, when she’s awake acts strangely. Readers want Mira to get home safely, but they also want to know what’s up with these people.

Although the subplot of Mira wanting to get home to her mom is more young-adult oriented, the suspense is on par with adult thrillers. This is a fast, satisfying read and I recommend it to all readers who like thrillers.

Thanks for visiting – come back soon!

18 thoughts on “Book Review: Five Total Strangers by Natalie D. Richards

    1. Hi Lynette – I was thinking the same thing and I’m glad you brought that up. I think reluctant young readers can get turned off by books because they think they will be boring or too hard. I thought this one was relevant and suspenseful. Thanks for visiting!

  1. I’m going to read this one – then see if I can recommend it to my 14-year-old granddaughter, going into high school. Maybe too much for her? I get really really suspense(d) when reading thrillers… we’ll see how I do. 🙂

    1. Hi Pam, I hope you like it! I think it would be okay for a 14-year-old. It’s not very violent and while there is some language (we call them the “worst” word and the “second worst word” here at home), I think it’s probably pretty realistic and not overdone. As for content, you can decide – but I think it’s probably okay. Let me know what you thin and thank you for stopping by. I’m way behind in replying to comments, but I’m plodding along and making progress!

Comments are closed.